Hard Refresh on automation
Listen on
Around the table
- Kirsty O’Connellequ.
Sophie WinterAustralian Wildlife Conservancy
Coming to SOS27?
| Dates | 24 & 25 August 2027 |
| Venue | Optus Stadium, Perth |
| Tickets | On sale 11 January |
Listen on
Hard Refresh · episode 06
Watch 28 min
Transcript
Automatic captions, names checked:
[0:05] Hello, welcome to Hard Refresh, the official podcast from State of Social 2025. What are we doing here, you might ask? Well, we’re polishing off our standard issue State of Social Crystal Ball and looking into the future to discover what’s in store for the next 25 years of digital marketing. We’re going to take a look at what trends, what technologies, what cultural shifts and maybe even controversies will shape this industry and in turn society at large. My name is Andrés López-Varela. Please call me ALV. All my friends do. And today we’re recording on the traditional lands of the Whadjuk Noongar people live at State of Social 2025. Coming up in this episode, we do a hard refresh on automation. Automation has really stopped being a feature and it’s become the operating system for marketing. In the next 25 years, ad platforms will push objective
[0:57] level end-to-end automation while customer engagement and content operations lean on AI to scale faster than we humans can even brief. The focus of strategy will shift to orchestration. But that creates a control versus performance question. Results, of course, yes, might improve, but control levers and transparency might vanish. So, we’re going to do our best to draw a hard line between what to automate, what never to automate, and how to prove value when dashboards disappear. Joining me to peer into the future of automation is Kirsty O’Connell, a senior account director and experienced digital strategist at digital agency equ.. Kirsty, how are you? Good, thank you. Thanks for being here. Very happy to be here.
[1:38] Thank you. and Sophie Winter, the national manager of content and communities at Australian Wildlife Conservancy. Welcome, Sophie. Excited for this? Yeah, I can’t wait. Excellent. Excellent. Everyone enjoying their State of Social so far as well? Loving it very much so. First- timers? Yes. Yes. Great. Good. Well, you know, the more we indoctrinate, the better, I say. Hopefully, you enjoy the rest of your time here as well. And this is uh a fun chat. Everyone ready? Let’s do it. Ready? Let’s do a hard refresh. All right. I’m going to ask us to draw some lines in the sand to start with to see where we all stand, right? Automation, as we
[2:14] know, promises like great results, but it takes over the controls. We sort of like we’re sitting in the front seat and we’re sort of like slightly blindfolded and and our hands are off the wheel. Um, right now, where do you think that we should refuse to automate? And, um, Kirsty, I want to start with you. Like, is it the development of creative concepts? Is it like the delivery of ads? Measurement and optimization of ads? Is it customer communications? Give me a sense of where you think we should be drawing a line on this, you know, process and culture of automation. Yeah, I think it sits across all those things which probably isn’t uh simple answer. Yeah. But I think uh there’s a really clear role for
[2:56] automation right now and I don’t think that’s going to change too much in the future. I think the role of automation is to um one create efficiency. Yep. But I think the role that that needs to be human and needs to remain human is how you then bring in that experience as part of that efficiency because we can scale. But if we scale and we’re not thinking about that experience, you’re creating something that doesn’t feel human, that doesn’t feel personal, and you’re losing that authenticity that can only really come from, I think, a human input and the emotional input that machines, I don’t think, can achieve. It’s fair enough. And do you think that that emotion and that that sense of connection to the work is something that future generations of marketers will
[3:40] have to be, you know, taught? Will that be a learned skill because because of the of the environment they’re walking into? Yeah. Well, I think it’s a really exciting time to be new to the industry. I think if you’re thinking about your role as a future leader right now, your role is going to be super exciting because you you are so easily going to be pulled out of the weeds, pulled out of delivery, pulled out of figuring out all of the um technical nuances of the the micro level. and your role will become much more about strategy, much more about the reason we all do this job and the reason why we’re all thinking about these things and the reason why we get up in the morning um and care about the work we do. Your role is to really think
[4:23] about where we take it, what that looks like, how it evolves, and how you do the best thing for your customer and how you give them the best experience. So, I think we all try to do that now, but we’re we’re spinning so many plates. I think it’s so easy for us to fall back into the weeds and fall back into delivery. Yeah. So, yeah, super exciting time and yeah, I think yes, needs to be taught, but in in no uh different way to the way we need to be taught about our jobs now. I think it’s just looking at from a different lens. Yeah, fair enough. Fair enough. Sophie, what about you? 100% agree. Yeah, I think there’s so many things that we can streamline using automation and using AI. So, scheduling, optimizing, even curating certain messages. But where we don’t want to lose out is that human voice and that
[5:08] authenticity that comes from having somebody that knows the subject and is a subject expert, having them edit and refine and create most of the copy surrounding the content that we’re putting out on our channels. And I also think that humans should be still involved in the moderation process particularly on social media where um there’s audience skepticism there is an overwhelming amount of bot talk as people say um yeah that human approach is still very much needed. So you draw a line or you’d ring fence the development of creative and content and community management. the other areas you think that it’s okay maybe to
[5:51] lean into automation more than those. Is that fair to say? Definitely. Yeah. Creating content and curating the community should be still human. Everything else can be automated. Yeah. Cool. What do you think? I think that’s really important. Yeah. So, I’ve actually been in this position where I’ve tried to lean into automation. Yes. Especially in social media and it’s been really difficult to let go and it’s not made easy for us by the platforms. No, no, no. Yeah, they don’t want automation either really.
[6:20] Yeah, to an extent. Exactly. So, I think they want you to lean into the capability. Um, but the way they’re exploring it at the moment and the way they’re um bringing us into that kind of world is a test and learn approach for them as well as us. So when we’re thinking about how we let go of the rain so automation can do the work and we can um get ourselves out of the weeds as we say um we’re losing some of that uh we’re losing some of the knowledge that what we’re putting in front of our customers is the quality of the brand and reflects our brand um values and ethos and how we want to be presented to our customers.
[7:02] Um really good example of this is when uh we were looking at how we use meta to automate a lot of our activity in the performance marketing space. And what we found was we were throwing in the creative and we were letting it do its work. And we were finding that the creative wasn’t appearing in the way that we expect it to in all environments. And that’s fine because that’s some of the control you lose in the world we’re in with automation. Part of the trade, isn’t it? Yeah. Yeah. But then we were getting questions about why that was happening. Yeah. And it’s very difficult to have those guard rails in place in that environment, but also let the reins go and let the AI do the work.
[7:39] Yeah, controversial opinion, but I hate the meta AI tool for performance marketing. Really, I think the creative is awful. Um, it spits out these customized versions of what you’ve put in. The audience targeting is also very hit and miss. So, for example, we ran a feral cat campaign that was meant to be targeted at an audience of conservationists and people who were advocating for native wildlife, but because we used cats in the imagery of this ad creative, it sent it like we used the broad targeting as a as a test with the meta’s AI and it sent it straight into the feeds of cat lovers. So, we just received all of this hate from people who are saying, “How are you killing feral cats? What’s the difference between domestic and feral?
[8:27] And I just created this warfare. Wow. Yeah. Yeah. So, that was about six months ago. Haven’t tried it again. Um, very Okay. You badly burned. I was badly burned off this one case, but yeah, it it is advancing and I think it’ll get to a point where it is a lot better. Yeah, the platforms are learning as we’re learning and I think that does serve a purpose for thinking about the level of control that we give at this stage. I think in the future to your point that will change considerably as we all figure out how this should look and how that will evolve. Um for now I think there’s definitely some caution to be put in place.
[9:03] Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well actually I wanted to get um nerdy on a little bit of that now um with you like particularly on ad tech right um so as ad buyers and creatives as we have just talked about are getting stitched together by machines and models and AI. Um, this is a great example that you gave, Sophie. Brand safety. It doesn’t just mean like lists of URLs anymore. It me, this is a great example, the feral cat with the with the cat with the cat. I mean, I’m a cat owner. If I’d seen that, I mean, I think hopefully I would understand, but maybe I’d have a visceral reaction to it. But, um, tell me, Kirsty, what do you think suitability will look like in this in the next 5 years when those models are making the decision? Yeah.
[9:46] And your hands are off the wheel. M I think that will be the role of marketers. I think it will be so much more about how you create that authenticity and that trust with your customer. And to be able to do that, you need to be much closer to how that evolves and what that looks like when it lands into an ad space. Yes. So you’re right, it will go way beyond lists of places we want to show up and places we don’t want to show up, topic areas and things. Yeah. But I also think there’s a ton of technology happening to help us to do that as well. And that’s all in the automation side of things. So you get some really incredible um scenarios and um work with some really interesting groups that look at how we can evolve in that space and how we can do it in a
[10:28] much easier way and how we can have that control. Um so yes, I do think there’ll be an even more important role to play, but I do think there’ll be help to be able to um facilitate doing that. Yeah, I it’s kind of hard for me to visualize in five years time if our hands will totally be off the wheel because right now as we’ve spoken about the AI is not quite at a level. I think there was a lot of hype around it and now we’re kind of plateauing and and seeing the real impact that human marketers still need to have on the AI content and moderation and and advertising streamlining that’s happening. So to try and visualize a completely hands-off approach from from humans is is quite tricky right now. But I know we need to because it’s probably coming.
[11:14] Yes. And certainly I think obviously like it’s true that a lot of the financial pressures in marketing are the answer to a lot of the questions are is automation you know like how do we reduce how do we do more with less the answer is automation. AI is you know I guess part of automation but automation is something which you know without AI could still really affect that right so and you know automation can really help us as we as we said and as you both have mentioned scale creative variance scale the new content we’re producing but I think as you both said audiences will still be like listening out for the brand right like that’s still really key so Sophie maybe tell us what you think is the sort I want to call it the MVP of creativity that we should be teaching these tools
[12:02] to maintain as like the minimum the minimum viable product. So we can still obviously use them and move at speed and get the advantages of them particularly you know in the future but without losing the stuff which makes the brand sing. What do you think is sort of that MVP? Yeah well I guess the foundations of good marketing is having a really strong brand USP and brand voice and um key messages. So feeding those into the the automation processes and the AI that we’re using in our workflows is so important so they learn those humanistic kind of um yeah principles of of our work. Um do you think that can be taught to the machines?
[12:45] Yeah. Well, I guess tone of voice it’s it’s a great question. Yeah. I guess it’s it’s the trial and error really. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. And essentially these tools get better as we teach them those things. But then we also take our hands further off the wheel. And you know I think I think you know looking at the next 5 10 20 years that will probably be the case. I think you know I just don’t know if it can I don’t know if I’m being very cynical. That’s okay. You can be it’s a safe space to be cynical. Okay. Good. Yeah. Because because I feel like the creativity I don’t think it can come from a machine. I think the machine
[13:20] is doing the functional work and removing some of that um some of the actions required to get things off the ground and get them delivered and get the optimization working. And I think the machine learning the the value you get from that is them is the machine understanding where your audience is, what they look like, but the emotional side of it and the context I think is so important and I think that has to come from a human. And I think nodding furiously. I I 100% agree. I don’t think some of the the big tech in Silicon Valley would agree because they’re saying that these robots are learning empathy and emotion and they’re going to be able to replicate what humans can give them. And um yeah, it’s a it’s a wild concept to
[14:06] think about, but potentially in in the future that maybe we have to get there. Yeah. Yeah. That was that was fun and light and breezy, you know, not not dark at all that conversation, but I want to go a bit more dark now. Okay, I want to say let’s pretend it’s like say the year 2035. Okay, media, creative, content agencies that don’t have some kind of secret source or proprietary, you know, way of thinking or approaching marketing are pretty much dead, right? Automation has eaten all this lowhanging fruit. Um and brands only hire the thinkers who are there to come up with that orchestration strategy of like what happens in what order and what are the rules and that’s really the the role for you
[14:58] know freelance consultant agencies how’s that hot take is that too harsh I think so yeah I think so I’m not just saying this because I work for an agency course I have worked brand side as well and I I think my view on this is that the roles will just shift. Yeah. So, I think I I said this earlier, we all want to be doing the stuff that is the bigger picture thinking. We want to do the strategic thinking, the stuff that’s going to really shift the dial for our brand or our clients. Yes, that’s what we all care about. And I hear time and time again the clients that we work with saying, “We want more strategic thinking from you.” But the challenge is they’re also relying on us to deliver.
[15:38] Yes. So it’s really challenging for an agency at the moment to balance both of those things and get them both right and get them in the right balance and we are doing it. I think in time when that’s taken over by the machines when it’s taken over by automation when we lose some of that um necessity of what headcount we need on an agency team we have so much more space to do that bigger picture thinking now I think your brand team their role is going to be so important in giving that direction and they will have more space to think about where we want to go what that should look like what we know about our audience and then the agency role is going to be really cool because they’re going to have the opportunity to say, “Hey, did you know that in 5 years or so, we think we’re going to be here? What are you doing to think about that? Let us help you.” Yeah.
[16:23] And the conversations are going to be so much richer. Yes. And so much more interesting. Not saying they’re not interesting now, but I think those interesting conversations are what we all want now, but they are hard to get. And we have to make very dedicated time to have those conversations. Yeah. And and it’s true that that is expensive that time as well. like as an agency that that time those resources are generally more expensive and so you know scaling that is is challenging. What will the role just to um ask you a question what will the role of the agency be then if you are using automation for your clients why would why would the clients come to you and not just automate themselves that’s going to be like we’re saying we still need to be
[17:02] the orchestrators so I guess the role of the agency will change as well absolutely yeah it will definitely change and I think um to answer your question I think if I was still in my brand role I would still have a lot of plates spinning. And um for me it feels like if I can remove some of those plates that feel a little bit more um getting things done in the weeds, delivery, the busy work, then um that gives me space to think about, you know, my strategy, how I manage in state internal stakeholders, where I want to take the brand, how I evolve that, how I get more investment behind what I want to do and how I bring my team up through that and start to empower them to think much bigger about where we can be and what ambitions we can have. I wouldn’t have time to think about where the industry is going.
[17:54] Yeah. You know, some of the bigger digital considerations of of what I need to be thinking about in five years time. Some of the some of these conversations, for example, even I don’t think I’d have the headsp space still to think about what I need to be to to be ahead of my where I need to be to be ahead of my competition and also where I need to be to be industry leading. I think I’d still very much rely on an agency. Yes. To help me with that steer. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Makes a lot of sense. And maybe then also actually the automation is something that becomes, you know, I guess more embraced in that
[18:28] sense. And then the career trajectory, you know, particularly of like the baby marketers that are starting now changes to be more about okay, you don’t need to worry about like optimizing ads or you don’t need to worry about like, you know, uh development of different variations or whatever like actually actually you know we want you to dedicate more of your time towards thinking about the larger the larger. I think that would be music to their ears as well. Yeah. Yeah. It would definitely be music to my ears 10 years ago. Oh gosh. tell you straight straight to the strategy be great.
[19:00] Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, you know, add a bit of life experience, I guess, right? Um, okay. I want to go like right into the future now. Putting on your like very futuristic glasses. If the machines are automating uh all the grunt work as we’ve just said, you know, which would be ideal and you know, whether it’s creative development, content creation, media planning, buying and it’s doing all that like well like you know, we got it right. Yay. Yay us. You know what roles are left in marketing then for humans that are not thinking roles? Is there any other path other than thinking is there? I don’t actually know.
[19:43] Analyzing, streamlining, creating content, conversing with audiences. If all of those can be automated, then what is left besides the strategy and the thinking and the presenting, the pitching? Yeah. Yeah. Does that make us a less essential function in business? I mean, if we’re saying if all of that is automated, yes, I don’t have trust that it will be because I think we’ve seen this kind of massive rise with the internet, with social media platforms, and now we’re seeing it with AI, generative AI. I think it will slow and and we won’t be as impressed in the future as we are with it right now. Probably true. Yeah.
[20:25] But yeah, if that does happen, I it’s terrible. But I can’t think of something that marketing that role would be still critical. Yeah. Yeah. What do you think? I think it’s more essential. Yeah. Yeah. I think our role will become more essential. Yeah. Um, I think it’s going to become more important than ever to be a skilled marketer in the industry because you can’t be lost in the doing and you can’t hide behind um that busy work. Yeah. Yeah, that’s true. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, I think again kind of goes back to what I said earlier about it being a really exciting time to join the industry. I’m not trying to recruit by
[21:04] the way, I promise. But I think you marketing needs you. But I do. Yeah. I think um over the next 10 years or so you’ll see us having to really level up on what our role is and I think that’s really important and really exciting. Well, let me ask you then like speaking about this topic then and speaking about this junior baby marketers that are coming you know into the industry now perhaps what are we teaching them to be ready for this kind of future? Are we teaching them data science? Are we teaching them ethics? Are we teaching them what you said so like taste? Are we teaching them prompt engineering? you know, like of probably like a little bit of everything, but what would you say are kind of the top skills, you know,
[21:44] now compared to like when you entered the industry? So, yeah. Oh, totally different. And you just saying prompt engineering has prompted me to think that that is a core skill that people will still need to learn um that marketers will will need to be good at in order to automate all of the rest of the busy work. So, teaching them prompt engineering and also strategic thinking. I don’t think marketers should move into data science. I see those as two distinct careers that should probably stay that way. But they will need to have some understanding and oversight of how data science works and and how to analyze what the automations are providing them in order to to feed into that strategy. I completely agree. Yeah. I think measurement is so important.
[22:28] Yes. and validating everything because what won’t change is the customer experience. What won’t change is they won’t see that it’s a machine versus someone manually placing that in a platform. They wouldn’t care either. They wouldn’t care. So the experience doesn’t change. It just becomes an opportunity to be much more tailored and much more personalized and we’re moving in that direction anyway. So it’s important for us to do that and embrace it. And if we can use automation to get there faster and be much more clever with our marketing, then it really gives us that opportunity to make sure that everything we’re doing is working as it should be, is right for
[23:09] the customer, and we’re getting that data and feedback as a constant to evolve our marketing activity. It’s definitely helping create smarter marketers. I’m seeing a lot more marketers who would have usually had the soft softer skills like content creation and um copywriting now looking at the data quite often that AI is giving them and using tools to their advantage. Yeah, it’s definitely holding us to account. It’s great. Yeah, I kind of like it. I sort of I like the idea that maybe we could probably get more back to a more holistic view and I sound like the oldest person in the room, but a more holistic view of marketing that’s not just promotion, but that it’s product development. It’s, you know, pricing, it’s it’s placement,
[23:51] understanding your audience, you know, cuz those are all functions of marketing that the all the P’s, right? You know, like that’s actually marketing. It’s not just promotion is just one aspect of marketing. And there’s so much more that we can do to maybe turn around to the to the business and go, we’ve got the grunt work covered. Let’s talk about what we know about our audience that can influence product development, for example. That’s really interesting, especially like in in in your work. Um, so for you know not for profofits and charities sometimes there’s a big gulf between like what the audience likes and knows you know like the response you get to the feral cat ad and actually the way that that you know the organization is structured to achieve its goals I guess. Yeah definitely and it will help in future with low resource industries like nonprofits and small businesses so they can automate
[24:40] and deliver more. Yeah absolutely. Yeah. Yeah. All right before we wrap it up we have just enough time for the refresh round. These questions are more random and you know you can be as hot as you want with these hot tags. No holds. Okay. In 2050, will brands still exist or will we have hit refresh on the whole idea? Wow, that’s a hell of a question. Yeah, I think brands will still exist. We’ll still be selling products. We’ll still be selling ideas and and businesses. I think the idea of brands and brand marketing needs to still exist in the future.
[25:13] Yes. Otherwise, we’re all in a bit of trouble, aren’t we? Yeah. Yeah. What’s one marketing buzz word, Kirsty, that you would re refresh straight into the garbage? Oh, okay. Scale. Scale. Tell me why. Not necessarily a buzz word, but I think we use it in the wrong way. Okay. We just talk about automation to scale what we’re doing rather than doing it with the right reason. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That’s good. That’s the right purpose.
[25:43] Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That’s good. As opposed to doing just more for more sake. Yeah. All right. If AI got a chance to refresh your job description, what would it throw out? AI got a chance to refresh my job description. Um, I mean, it would probably throw out all of it. Just having having discussed what we just discussed, it would research the whole thing and be like, “We don’t need you. Thanks so much.” You’re now the strategic director and I do everything else. So, maybe some great handover notes and that’s it. I like that. I like easy. Um, if you could refresh the internet for the better, which one channel or platform would you get rid of?
[26:19] X. You know what? That’s coming up a lot. That’s coming up a lot. Formerly known as Twitter. Twitter. Still Still Twitter in our hearts. Yeah. It died when Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. We don’t need to say. Yeah. We know. And when Gen Alpha refreshes marketing and looks back at us, what do you think is the one thing they’ll roast us for the most? still being stuck in campaign delivery. Oh yes. Yes. And planning for campaigns rather than planning for customer needs. Yes. I like that. That’s good. That’s good. That’s good. Yeah.
[26:53] I hope they roast us for that. We deserve to be roasted for that, honestly. Yeah. Oh, I love this conversation. I had no idea where we’re going to kind of head with this, but um I’m really grateful for all the kind of honesty and clarity in that chat. I think we we you know, we solved a lot of problems there, right? Yeah. Yeah. Just automate everything. Done. Kirsty O’Connell, Sophie Winter, thank you so much for joining me on the podcast and I hope you enjoy the rest of State of Social. Thank you. Thanks so much. Great to be on. Thank you. If you like this refreshing conversation, you’re going to love the rest of Hard Refresh. Join me and the smart minds of the State of Social 2025
[27:25] crew as we get into all the big topics so you know where we’re headed for the next 25 years of digital marketing. The podcast is now live across all your favorite podcasty places. And make sure you do what your parents taught you. Sharing is caring. Tell a mate or two if you like what you hear and give us a five-star review because I asked you to, but also because it helps other people discover the show. Hard refresh is a co-production of State of Social and Original Audio. The show is produced by me, Andrés López-Varela, and Aaron Matthews from Original Audio. Big shout out to Cal McClain for production support and our executive producer, Meg Coffey. I’m ALV. Thanks for tuning in. Remember to tune in again next time when I’ll hit refresh on something new all over again.
Automation is no longer just a tool. It’s becoming the operating system of marketing. In this episode of Hard Refresh, host Andrés López-Varela is joined by Kirsty O’Connell (Senior Account Director, equ.) and Sophie Winter (National Manager, Content & Communities, Australian Wildlife Conservancy) to debate the promises and pitfalls of automation.
From Meta’s AI gone wrong with a feral cat campaign for the Australian Wildlife Conservancy to the risks of handing brand safety over to machines, the panel dives into where humans should still hold the reins. Together they ask: when everything can be automated, what’s left for marketers to do ?
In this episode:
// Where humans still matter
Both guests argue that community management, creative concepting, and tone of voice should remain human-led, automation can optimise and scale, but only people can bring context, empathy, and credibility.
// When automation backfires
Sophie recalls a feral cat awareness campaign that Meta’s AI targeted to cat lovers, sparking outrage. It’s a cautionary tale about brand safety when platforms make decisions without context.
// Losing control of creative
Kirsty explains how automated ad placements distorted campaign assets in ways the team didn’t expect, a trade-off of efficiency for oversight that left clients asking hard questions.
// Agencies as orchestrators
Rather than being replaced, agencies may thrive by helping brands navigate orchestration, strategy, and ethics once automation eats the “busy work.” Both panellists argue this will shift agency-client conversations to bigger, more interesting questions.
// Future-proofing talent
Skills like prompt engineering, measurement, and critical thinking are becoming the new basics for junior marketers. The panel sees automation forcing marketers to level up, reclaiming marketing as more than “promotion” and returning to its roots in product, pricing, and audience insight.
This episode was recorded on the traditional lands of the Whadjuk Noongar people, live at State of Social ’25.
All episodes of Hard Refresh are now live on YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts and other podcast players.

Take this with you
- Automate scheduling and optimisation, but keep copy written by a subject expert and keep people moderating comments, where bots and sceptical audiences gather.
- When you hand performance campaigns to Meta’s automation, check how your creative actually renders in each environment, and be ready to explain it when clients ask.
- Avoid broad AI targeting when your imagery could attract the wrong crowd: feral cat ads with cats in them went straight to cat lovers.
- Feed your brand USP, tone of voice and key messages into every AI tool in your workflow so automated output still sounds like you.
- Once automation covers the grunt work, take what you know about your audience back to the business to shape product development and pricing.
Keep reading
- State of social indexHere’s how social really works in Australia
- SOS26Nine years in, and the theme argued back
- Delegate resourcesThe reading list
