Organic content: the hottest takes
Listen on
Around the table
Scotty McDonaldABC Radio Brisbane
Edwin SmithThe Social Sandwich
Georgia Tappysocial media consultant
Coming to SOS27?
| Dates | 24 & 25 August 2027 |
| Venue | Optus Stadium, Perth |
| Tickets | On sale 11 January |
Listen on
The Alchemists · episode 09
Transcript
Automatic captions, names checked:
[0:01] I think choosing not to do organic content on social media in 2024 is lazy like that’s it that’s it full stop hello and welcome back to the Alchemists a limited series podcast from State of Social 2024 that you’ll quickly come to love as much as Meg Coffey loves dogs my name is Andrés López-Varela uh and you can call me a you can also call me The Internet’s number one fan of cats and that actually causes a lot of problems between me and I uh we’re working through it though and today we are recording on the traditional lands of the wak Nar people at live at stateof Social 2024 based on some of the questions actually I’ve been hearing from the audience so far and you know with the whisperings in the corridor I think this conversation is going to be very uh relevant for a lot of our audience um and we have assembled a
[0:48] crack team of Alchemists to get their hottest takes on all things organic content you’re going to absolutely love this chat before we dive in I just want to remind you the whole series of the Alchemists is now live wherever you get your podcasts so make sure you hit that subscribe button to see all the episodes in your feet and with that it’s time to make the magic happen I’m happy to welcome our Alchemist for this episode including Scotty McDonald Deputy content director at ABC radio Brisbane hello Scotty hello thank you for being here no thank you for having me Georgia Tappy social media and marketing consultant hello Georgia hi hi welcome and Edwin Smith Instagram expert founder CEO of The Social Sandwich how are you Edwin I’m doing good good thanks for the the nice intros excited to be here live live live at St audience in front of a small studio audience CA a crew yeah yeah yeah what you don’t know is this an episode of hot one so you’re hot spicy WIS I love hot
[1:44] wings so I love Hot are they coming no that was a bad joke sorry I’m out you’re out well let’s get speaking well but we do want your hot takes that’s why we’re here today and um I want to start uh by asking you Georgia um the nature right like obviously social media has changed so much you know every every every you know major minor change over the past few years a lot of big changes thanks to the pandemic of course um and how we ourselves change the way that we consume content um but a lot of those changes are also thanks to the technology itself and the way that the social media companies and platforms want us to engage with their products so they make some some dollars you know um so I’m wondering given where we are with the State of Social uh media right now what even is organ content in 2024 and I
[2:32] think also what definitely isn’t organic content in 2024 such a good question the way I normally frame it when I’m talking to Brands is try and create content the same way an influencer would so without any idea of money or campaigns or trying to you know convert and all these marketing speak that we think of obviously we’re doing it very deliberately but that that sort of loose realistic um approach to content creation is how I Define it but I would love to hear because I know you Scotty have have slightly different opinions than I do about what is organic content no I think we we might be pretty close I in this morning’s opening keynote Michael Cochran said uh the two reasons that people go to social media uh the
[3:17] first one was to be entertained and the other one was I’m pretty sure it was along the lines of to get out of their shitty life to escape which is just such a joyful thought anyway I would say organic is when your goal is to actually hit one of those two things that’s the starting point of organic if you’re creative and you’re clever and you also turn it into a CTA or you also turn it into a business thing cool but if the content itself feels like the original goal was to hit one of those two that to me is organic that’s interesting I think that’s a really good way to fight what do you think mate I’m just glad that wasn’t the first question that I had because that was a one straight up technology the state of the world how human beings are responding yeah very
[4:04] easy for me to answer really wild up right away now I yeah very much on the same page I think the the entertainment factor is something that I think and talk about a lot when I think a lot of Brands think of social media as a marketing tool to sell their product which is ultimately what the goal is but if I just think if you go in with the goal of trying to sell a product or sell a service then it’s not going to work I think the first goal has to be to engage people through interesting relevant entertaining content and then like Scotty said then you can think about you know incorporating some ctas at the end of a you know an interesting funny reel or you know working those messages throughout but I think you’ve got to get the people there interest interest and engaged first and then you can start thinking about the you know the cell second do we feel like there anything
[4:52] that maybe used to be quote unquote organic content that maybe now we feel it doesn’t fit into that very good definition that you guys just uh you know came up with I guess is it controversial to say images because maybe not and that’s a very broad um a very broad answer but I think you think back to kind of you know pre pandemic times when the organic reach was much higher so you could post a photo of a product and be like hey here’s this cool product we got go and buy it and you know 50% of your audience would see that post on Instagram let’s say whereas now that number would be like 10% let’s yeah if that and so um you know there’s still a place for you know a good but like it was a free hit right so like as a brand you could be like let’s just go and sell stuff and I think people still think that I can post to
[5:42] their social platforms with a product shot people will see that and I’ll go buy my product they go that doesn’t work especially now Instagram gives us 20 images in a carousel which arguably is 18 images too many reverting back to like the internet when it was 20 years ago when it was like Tumblr and blogs like it’s just all become we’re all just conglomerating to one thing it’s a bit depressing I think the platforms are forgetting they are meant to be individual platforms but anyway I digress can I ask a question off your answer to this question probably to spicy T to I love it the Spicer the better don’t post images ever um just for this one Tik Tok seem to have signaled like almost lukewarmly signaled that they’re interested in an image sharing app does does does image sharing have a future in the near future yet or is Tik
[6:30] Tok just throwing mud against a wall to see what sticks I think the platforms are doing what people keep asking them to do that’s why they are there that’s how they make money by responding to the needs of the consumers so they’re hearing from people who maybe went around for the Facebook insta ages like these gen Z that yeah they want to see more images so this is the sad thing as we’re getting old guys like now when you said these gen um yeah old man shaking his hand fist yeah but I think it’s Lally that they didn’t realize that that was a platform that we used to use 15 years ago so now it has become like that’s Tik tok’s what they currently use so I guess it’s like you know the the the you know to give more old man Cloud Vibes the kids these days take their parents Sony Cyber shots yeah out online out take photos rather than just posting every single thing then they relive it the
[7:19] next day together and then they select the ones they curate the more careful with it than we were yeah they’re a bit more careful so maybe that’s where it’s coming from right it could be that um but I guess regardless of the format of the content and whether you think images are not organic content or not and that’s certainly I hope going to in you know um inform some debate and commentary one of the biggest trends that continues to define the content that we do see online that works well and Ed when you talk about this a lot is a sort of low production value Scrappy sort of rough content maybe not lowf but sort of should we say lowish F I guess uh as a range it seems that this especially in video right it seems there’s definitely no going back to that polished cont ENT um that higher in production kind of values so I’m interested to know who you think is
[8:04] leading this change now is it still the creators and their audiences or have the platforms decided that this is totally dead this this way of creating content can I disagree with you I don’t think Loi is the way of the future I think it is a moment in time right now because post pandemic we were all stuck in our homes Brands didn’t have access to fancy photo shoots and you know glossy editing so people started producing a lot more stuff we started to get used to in our feeds but everything people will start to revolt against that and go I don’t want to see another blurry crappy caption I want to see something produced with value and thought and consideration I think there’s space for both of them in the future but what’s your timeline on that oh God I’m not a futurist I have no idea but no I think it’s a really interesting point but are we talking 5 10 20 no I’m in the couple next couple years I reckon
[8:51] I don’t think the pendul is going to swing back absolutely I mean look call me wrong in like yeah call me up in 3 years time I’ll be wrong but you heard it here first I feel like the core of it is the storytelling right and it’s like what tools do you have for your story if you have access to the means of producing a beautiful you know TV show great go for it but if you only have an iPhone and Camera like yeah go for that instead cuz the there’s an interesting thing that I think about all the time the early days of YouTube like those really really big creators that did what I guess what we called vlogging at that time but even like Epic Meal Time they started off really low fight and ended up producing C and TV shows bubish you know like great example sort of swayed back and forth actually but I know Ed when you have a very firm
[9:39] view on this about about how about that sort of divide between you know um higher production value polished and then more kind of rough and ready so you know um Enlighten us I’m kind of I actually do kind of agree that I I don’t think it’s as clearcut now is everything should be you know really low fine Scrappy and um you know look look a bit I think it’s more and this is something that I I’ve been talking about for years like even back you know from working in TV it was always the thinking that I always had was people want like content they want to be engaged I want something that’s that’s interesting and I don’t think it now matters how that’s presented if it’s a really well edited put together video or if it’s you know a selfie on an iPhone with like a crappy ring light that just you know it looks okay but it’s it’s like if there’s something there you know if it’s funny if it’s interesting if it’s educational
[10:28] if they get something out out of it it doesn’t matter how it’s filmed or produced it’s like what matters is like the content behind it so and there’s going to be a place still for you know the the shinier pieces of content but then at the same time it’s like you could potentially deliver that same piece of content just in a you know in an easier way it’s obviously easier than ever to edit videos now as you know anyone is a influencer or I even think now I don’t even think influencers exist in my mind like I think creators exist influencers are now like I think you know influencers take photos of things and say buy my product which as we know photos are dead and just established that we established that and so I think that yeah just that the video piece um is now so important yeah creators are definitely like the the way of the future and I think just that that Scrappy type of content is is here but yeah there’s no reason why you can’t have a really a well shot piece that
[11:18] just still has has some value but I think there’s still definitely brands that think let’s make something look really cool and then that’s the value they think they’re giving when it’s like just because something looks nice and shiny and like you know has slick edits and like graphics and stuff like doesn’t mean it’s going to perform can’t polish a turd basically like yeah I think that’s the problem with Brands is that they do have access to a lot more money than regular people and so they will throw expensive videographers and editing and all that at it to make something crap that isn’t that interesting whereas yes like you know anyone can just film a vlog and it could be a bit more interesting than anything a brand could produce so what I’m hearing really is that then these trends of the the style of production particularly in organic content is really being driven by by creators more than anything more than Brands perhaps more than the audience themselves and certainly more than the platforms does
[12:06] that sound about right or have I plucked that out of the air I think the other thing that we’ve kind of pled out of the air but I think it’s also just like General people like the this idea of like you know crappy pose yeah I feel like the when I first started seeing that style was just like the younger generation posting like image galleries to inst it was like a phot dump of their week and there was just like the worst assortment of photos they didn’t really think about it it was like screenshots of things like you know screenshots of Snapchat with like Snapchat texts and it was like this just looks so crap yeah but then that’s what you know the cool young kids are doing and it was like you know it was almost like the Revolt away from the perfect CA Fe that everyone was used to of like you know on Instagram you put up the perfect version of
[12:54] yourself on social media you know it’s yes you at a wedding and that’s it like you know looking your best right now like oh let’s just put up I I also think there’s a there is there is a driven by the audience Factor so I think a lot about when Tik Tok first came out and there was the talk of like you have to get people in the first 3 seconds and now it feels like it’s more like the first3 seconds but that drives to a place where like you know a a a big corporate marketing team would often be like well we need to open with our logo smooth transition out of the logo with a title card explaining what this video will be about man the moment I see your logo I’ve scrolled I’ve moved on and so production value to that level uh very much driven by the audience where people were just like not watching that not watching that not watching that the
[13:42] filter has become much stronger people can pick out and I think we’re lit this is the point is that we’re evolving the more Brands try and force us to be like watch my ad the more we become aware of it and we go I’m not going to you can’t make me unless you produce something that is worth watching so it’s almost like I think now the best almost like trick you into watching you don’t even realize and you get to the end you’re like wait crap that feeling as well we like oh you’ve just tricked me into watching an ad so it’s it’s almost no offense marketers can’t win and it’s like that’s what makes our job interesting right is this constant pushpull of like how can we keep creating beautiful work that sells the story that we’re trying to sell whilst not offending or upsetting the audience that we’ve built over many years hopefully yeah I think it’s very wise uh and so Okay so we’ve talked
[14:27] about what organic content is very I hope I get a compliment like that we’ll see we’ll see play your cards okay so we know we’ve talked a bit about what organic content is and what it isn’t we know it is in images as Edwin would us believe I told you I was going to give you some hot taste that one might two this is good this is good at The Social Sandwich come on me I’m ready and we know that and we know we think that there’s sort of a maybe a pendulum swing moment but also maybe a rebalancing right of that those different styles of content um and I think um what our marketer friends are going to naturally be asking is I get what this content is I get why the audience wants it but why even bother at all with posting content that isn’t paid to be seen in some way given all the technological forces kind
[15:14] of arrayed against you so I mean Scotty what do you think if we’re wedged into a corner by having to pay to reach audiences is organic content a feasible strategy at all uh how should it be Blended should people sort of be giving up on it or should they be doubling down on it I I want to make a really um I want to make a more spicy take than the image wow and it’s going to offend a lot of people yes yes St down the barrel then I um my name is Edwin Smith I think choosing not to do organic content on social media in 2024 is lazy like that’s it that’s it full stop because if you’re uh at a stage where we went through that process where the tiktock ification of social media means that we’re now seeing um even meta try
[16:02] and fight to make entertaining content go well where in one of those sweet spots where you actually can make good creative that without money behind it will get to an audience and arguably will get to the audience that is most likely to want to engage with it and if your response to that is oh but we can just force the audience to watch it by paying for it like let’s not let’s not pretend that it’s actually anywhere near as effective as content that you have specifically gone out and created to enter to entertain people but then the layer on top of that and I I’m I’m stealing this Theory from a a very well-known business marketing speaker who I’m not going to name because they’re polarizing um their last name has three
[16:50] syllables um but usually they short it to one syllable um but uh if you create organic content that goes really well then retail that content with a strong CTA and make that your paid creative because now as paid creative it’s going to go 10 times better than the ad you put together is going to go because you know people want to see it and interact with it and engage with it so really then the organic content is there to build the audience show you have common interests if you like and then you could sort of kindly ask them to click on your thing Scot are you saying paid is dead I am not what I’m saying is is that um when I think of of uh Interruption advertising which is how linear TV and how linear
[17:40] radio work and now how YouTube works and now how social works like literally I know you came to see this thing but but before you’re allowed to see this thing I’m going to make you hear about my business pay the toll like what a what an what a crazy C concept that that is and then to go onto social media and be like hey I know you’re here to get away from your stressful life but because I’ve paid money I’m allowed to make you hear about my brand like what a CRA it’s cocky it’s very like my brand or product is so good it’s going to interrupt your yeah your downtime your precious down time you’ve only got half an hour you’re going to be on the toilet or whatever scrolling through Tik Tok but no now I’m going to
[18:27] make you listen to what I to say and it is a bit it’s almost like bullying like yeah I’ve got enough money and you’re going to sit here and take it I’m so glad that you agree completely really worried marketers so and I think further to to that point for me the introduction of Tik Tok the you know reals exploding for me that’s someone that loves organic content that’s like the most exciting change that’s happened because the beauty of those platforms and those tools is you can be seen by people that don’t NE necessarily already follow and engage with you so there’s that discoverability element that we just haven’t had you know you’ve relied on Instagram through like hashtags or like the explore feed to grow before reals existed and that was really challenging whereas now it’s like if you make a real that is you know ticks all those boxes
[19:16] around engaging content it’s interesting it’s relevant to people then people not just your audience but people outside of that audience could potentially see that so for me I look at that as like such an opportunity for Brands to look at and go hey we can do something cool we can reach those people that we might have been able to pay for usually but now we can do that you know by just creating good content obviously that’s a really hard question it’s easy just to go you know let’s just throw some some marketing budget behind it to make sure more people see it but um I think that’s it’s exciting for me like I try and get people excited by organic content it’s like look at the opportunity like look at all these people that could potentially see what you’re yeah what you’re doing it is a mind frame thing as well where it’s like yeah I could serve you a bunch of ads and maybe your audience will watch them but will they actually be interested will they remember you that your not precious to you’re happy to annoy your
[20:05] audience Po and every gambling out ever on any streaming service catch up I work with a lot of clients who spun a lot of money into Tik Tok ads but they don’t actually have a Tik Tok organic strategy and I tell them people click on your Tik Tok ad they go to your profile and you have nothing to show for it and then they go ah all right and then they click out and it’s just it’s unfortunately how people use social media nowadays they’re not going to your web page necessarily so it kind of needs to be complimentary to and fro a conversation between the two ideally yeah I think that’s a really good way to put it I do think no like this kind of brings up a point which you know I find personally infuriating well I find this this um this uh contradiction sort of infuriating um diabolical um you know the lifespan of organic content is varies depending on the type of you know text image maybe
[20:53] not images have determined that they’re done you know video whatever it might be right um but but they get it’s getting shorter and shorter right the the lifespan and the relevance every everything is perishable I disagree okay let me finish my question then yeah maybe maybe is this on theable maybe I’ll correct maybe I’ll fix it up um so we’re creating more and more content right because in general the feeling is whether the content doesn’t last long you know like it’s lifespan is not long we can talk about that um or the fact that I’ve got to work so hard to kind of you know like be heard about the noise um we’re creating so much so much content so are we making it worse though by posting all this organic content are we sort of you know um if we want organic content to play a
[21:41] role to have a meaningful role in what we do shouldn’t we just call our Jets and like half of the volume of content should we all like sign a a Kyoto Protocol of content posting and just be like 50% of what we’re posting now question to Edwin maybe to start with oh I have so many thoughts on that um do you want to start with bit you disagree with me on that so I actually think that organic content especially in like talk about reals actually has like a longer lifespan than probably ever in terms of a good piece of content can be seen for days even weeks after when before this new and this is like a bit of like an algorithm shift where um you know you look at your Instagram feed like I guarantee you’ll see a post from 3 four days ago sometimes like weeks ago and that’s I think a good thing because it means that you know if and that’s the
[22:29] best content that does that it’s not every piece of content but it’s like again if you make a good piece of content it will be seen and work for you for you know a long period of time which is again that’s another yeah another good thing um so that that’s what I disagree with I think the other parts uh interesting and maybe I agree with you I had a real go viral last year in November it’s got over a million views at the moment and still to this day when I check it it has more and more views just because people keep sharing it amongst their friends and family and it’s wonderful for me obviously but it’s just it shows that yeah if you create a good piece of organic content it could potentially live forever whereas paid is set within you know 90 days 10 days whatever it is that campaign that you’re running for and then it’s kind of Gone Forever you can repurpose it maybe but that takes time and effort whereas organic yeah ideally can live for months
[23:16] maybe and I always think as well with you know this like agreement that we all signed it’s like okay we’re going to like post a little bit less to just make it a bit easier I actually think that is basically what the algorithm does right like it cuts out the the crap and that’s why you know while there isra yeah like but it’s the algorithm’s job from you know when I think about it is like to show us the best stuff and so if you make something just for the sake of it to like publish content like get things out there it’s it is actually harder now to get those you know the organic reach on content because there is competition for it so means we have to be better at content which I think is a good thing because if your content yeah if your content sucks it’s going to bomb and then you’re going like and people complain why don’t I get any reach anymore like it’s cuz the content sucks would you would you watch this would you pay attention to this no then why would your audience so do you remember those early days of threads where people would
[24:06] just like attacking Adam maeri the head of Instagram and being like you’ve taken away my reach I why are you entitled to reach oh my goodness right look at any any Instagram post he still does like the the comments are just like a fight amongst creators of like just give us what people want and let us blacklisted and you’re like you haven’t been blacklisted you start posting good content s yeah I always go and look at their profiles I’m like yeah your content his a whole bunch of like pretty photos I I saw a Creator a couple of weeks ago posted and said like oh my reach has being cut off and Instagram you’re the worst thing that’s ever happened and um and someone replied to them or they were like what should I do how do I reach my audience who followed me and someone replied and was like I reckon you should either start like a blog or a substack the person love substack replied with oh no I’m not that important that people would follow me
[24:57] there wait you have expectation that Instagram should force your content on people but you yourself admit that it’s not good content people need to go to the drawing board and again what is social media trying to solve what’s the problem you’re trying to solve if it’s to reach a wide variety of people then yeah organic content can be amazing but if it is like as you say if you don’t have anything interesting to say I don’t know I don’t actually know what the platform is for you then if you have nothing of value to add to the world why are you sharing your ideas in the first place and it’s interesting sorry so brutal no yeah this these are I’m here for it I still remember last year um so I have an old workmate that actually works at Instagram and I like I’m not allowed to talk not allowed
[25:42] to talk about her because um her emails get flooded oh she’s like if you ever give my email to anyone like I’ll never talk to you again I’m like that is fa enough but she told me you know she’s like look I’ve probably drunk the Kool-Aid a bit but she’s like I think people forget that these platforms are like a free tool that you can use for marketing like Instagram for business Facebook for business right unless you’re you’re paying like it’s a free tool you can use to promote your business so when there’s like all this entitlement of like well my followers should be seeing my content it’s like they’re running a business as well where they’re trying to make it an enjoyable place and so again it comes back to if your content sucks it’s not going to be seen and it is harder than ever to to do that but yeah there certainly is not with everyone but some people that like entitlement of all these followers why aren’t they seeing my posts without any kind of yeah it’s like I’ve been doing the same thing for 5 years but I do see their point of view though I think the
[26:30] problem maybe also is that sometimes content can become very homogeneous like we all want the same correct we get fatigued yeah we get fatigued so sometimes yeah maybe your content is so different and new that maybe the algorithm doesn’t even know where to put it I mean again it’s we don’t know how the algorithm Works anyone who says they do is lying to you um we are making clip that one put that educated guesses but yeah like its job then day is to keep people on platform so that Instagram Facebook whoever can make money from the ads so yeah if your content isn’t interesting or engaging people aren’t going to watch it they’re going to go out of the app and then Instagram loses so yeah it’s just a business decision at the end of the day sad but true like we’ve agreed on a lot of things I know weird I thought we were going to beef a bit more I think certainly the intensity of the of the views shared is way hotter than I thought so I think you’re all at
[27:17] that level of intensity and I think you’ve all brought yourselves up to that so I will flip this table if you make another comment about he’s playing Devil’s a I like it you said that you were here to do that I I have always thought that maybe actually I’m just an idiot with my thoughts about social media but now I know there’s at least three idiots using social media so I think that’s the point of the convention right is to meet other idiots and go is it is it your experience too because I thought it was just me amazing yeah shout out Meg thank you for that’s that’s literally you’re right that’s Meg’s mission statement so it’s good idiots together together all right before we wrap things up want to change things up I I have the feeling that this group is going to be perfectly okay with this next part of the conversation uh I’m going to um ask you to play fast and loose with your opinions oh no uh and I have some questions that I meant to make you uneasy uh and and and but
[28:06] just remember you are The Alchemist so you’re imbued with a special ability that means that you know you’re you’re protected basically for for whatever you say so I’m going to hit hit each one of you with a random question why am I sweating I know my Palms are sweating jeez got really CL I hit you with a random question and then you’re going to give me the answer pops into your head and the rest of us can you know agree disagree laugh at you support you whatever it is yeah I’m G to start with you Georg oh cool thanks I appreciate that so much I agree that’s so wrong how could you think that cool so as an alchemist you your teachings are a generous gift to the world except when you get something wrong in your career what’s the biggest thing you’ve been wrong about I think for me I often assume clients understand what I’m talking
[28:56] about the same way I do that like they are also obsessively online that they also follow the best creators and that they are constantly inspired by the best things and I realize that most business owners are pretty busy running a business and they’re not spending 20 hours a day on Tik Tok and yeah I guess trying to translate the layers of Internet subculture to people who have maybe better more important things to do um I’ve definitely failed at that before and yeah it’s something I’m constantly trying to improve upon because it is the only reason we have a job is to try and get people to understand understand that God that was a tough question I strugg with that all the time as well I mean there’s a lot of M here just make like you know a quick 10-second Reel with like you know hook at the start and then you go oh wait there’s like hours to unpack in that like one sentence what a what yeah like
[29:44] how to Ed videos and like how to make it engaging 11 seconds is that too long where’s the key messaging you haven’t thought about the key messaging no I haven’t I think people would like me to introduce myself at the start of this video oh they wouldn’t Ed here the brand name seven times um we can try that have our logo like covering the whole bottom half of the screen and direct people to the QR code down below like yeah that’ll work totally we we’ll try it we’ll give it a crack I would say yes and then I’ll come back with information being like look I tried your post and it sunk um can we try mine for 12 weeks and then if it works which it usually does perfect yeah cool s that’s good I appreciate that you sharing that Scotty oh no as an alchemist you you understand the important relationship the delicate
[30:30] balance between humanity and the natural world so who runs who who runs the natural world is it cats or dogs oh or dogs dogs of course it is yeah okay okay this idea this idea if you want a really spicy tag forget everything I’ve said so far this idea that cats enjoy being captive is hilarious it is true okay yeah I mean I mean like the I I think my cat’s pretty happy uh you know being what evidence do you have to that point lot of purring some sort like little kind of chin scratches and everything apart like it’s not that it hurts it’s not L yeah I mean the spiciness of these takes continue that
[31:15] was good though I liked it I liked it Edwin as an alchemist you make a magical compound in your Apothecary congratulations that can wipe out one of the social mediums just like that which one do you use it on and what why come on there’s only one answer I have a love hate relationship with a lot of the platforms I think that’s our job to be honest You’ got you’ve got one dose of this magical compound so you can only choose one Twitter but I also think Twitter’s kind of killed itself so then I’m like am I using my yeah so then I’m like maybe just take out Facebook and like you know then we don’t have to worry about like Facebook ever again that would be so L I’d forget a lot of birthdays but that proba be the only thing that I’d probably miss never having to deal with meta business I was going to say specifically
[32:00] business moly was that’s pretty that’s a deep cut yeah yeah my my third option was going to be LinkedIn just to kind of fire up the LinkedIn debate about chat afterwards I’ll fix your LinkedIn let’s let’s go Final Answer um Facebook great thank you and and that’s a great answer I think you know yeah I mean I killed a a few years ago in my life and it’s never it’s never been better you on Facebook no not on the book the book how do you remember birthdays I don’t how do you like keep up to date with the local happenings in the faceb grp goip so hold on slow down if you see a car drive up your street do a uturn and then drive back down the street where do you post that now I just talked to the cats about it yeah you’re like mentally well then that must be nice you’re maybe not well not
[32:47] well not well but better than I was in 2019 when I was L they got to got off before the pandemic anyway uh I am really happy we could do this what a wonderful um chat a fantastic breakdown of these Trends and you know sort of what’s important and also I guess the reassurance that organic content is uh is very important but also its roles matured and changed a lot so I’m very grateful for your time uh I appreciate you sharing your hottest spiciest takes uh thank you again and have a very excellent State of Social thank you thank you thank you there is plenty more to wrap your ears around on the Alchemists including heaps of in-depth chats with this year’s State of Social speakers so make sure you follow the show wherever you get your podcasts and if you like what you heard give us a festar review and tell a
[33:34] mate or two or three tell your mom the Alchemists is a co-production of State of Social and Creative Fix the show is produced by me Andrés López-Varela and Aaron Matthews from Creative Fix with additional production support by Cal McClain Meg Coffey is our executive producer on behalf of all the Alchemists I’m a I’ll catch you next time
Content fatigue is real. Or is it? Is it time to step off the organic content hamster wheel or lean into the next big trends? In episode 9 of The Alchemists, the last in our limited series podcast,we’re examining the changing role of organic content and exploring how to overcome content fatigue.

For this must-hear pod, our host Andrés López-Varela is joined by:
- deputy content director at ABC Radio Brisbane, Scotty McDonald
- founder/CEO of social media consultancy The Social Sandwich, Edwin Smith
- social media and marketing consultant Georgia Tappy.
Join our panel for a breakdown of what’s driving social media trends and how we can make the most of them, rather than be ruled by them. Our panellist will get into the big questions:
- What is ‘organic content’ in 2024, given how social platforms and tech have changed?
- What’s driving the shift from high production values to low-fi content creation?
- What kinds of organic content are different demographics engaging with?
- Are we, as marketers, creating a sense of content fatigue? And how can we beat it?
- And much, much more…
Take this with you
- When an organic post performs well, rework it with a strong call to action and run it as your paid creative.
- Drop the opening logo and title card from your videos: viewers scroll away the moment they see a brand intro.
- Build an organic profile before spending on TikTok ads, because people who click an ad check your profile, not your website.
- If a client wants their logo and brand name all over a post, run their version, then ask to trial yours for 12 weeks.
- Judge organic content by whether its first job is to entertain or give people an escape, and add the call to action after.
Keep reading
- State of social indexHere’s how social really works in Australia
- SOS26Nine years in, and the theme argued back
- Delegate resourcesThe reading list